Ithaca College, Criminal Charges, and Administrative Hearings

Sometimes as part of my representation of IC (Ithaca College) students they will request my attending their administrative hearings. Violations on campus and usually many of the dorms/apartments are part and parcel of campus property will often result in a separate college board hearing/review to determine what consequences/punishments/reprimands/suspensions/expulsion the student may face for their criminal charges.

Under the IC policy ANY attorney involvement in these is forbidden. This is a "one on one" meeting.

See highlighted code under (5.) below:

7.1.2.4 Administrative Hearing Process [IV]

As amended by the Ithaca College Board of Trustees April 14, 2000, October 13, 2006, and May 17, 2009.

When a nonacademic incident occurs involving an Ithaca College student's alleged violation of any rule or regulation outlined in the "Statement of Responsibilities," policies provided in section 7.1.2.3 or in the residential life rules and regulations, the matter will be handled according to the following procedures unless the incident occurs at the end of an academic year and involves a graduating senior. For an incident involving a graduating senior, the College shall be permitted to modify the steps in the hearing procedure to allow for resolution of the matter prior to commencement:

1.	The incident is documented.
2.	The documentation is then forwarded to the director of judicial affairs or other appropriate administrative hearing officer, who will determine if the student will be charged for the alleged violation(s) of the student conduct code.
3.	When a student is charged, the student will be notified in writing by the director of judicial affairs or other appropriate administrative hearing officer. This written notice will include the section(s) of the residential life rules and regulations and/or the student conduct code allegedly violated; a brief description of the incident; the date, time, and location of occurrence, if available; and an appointed time to meet with the designated hearing officer. The letter will include instructions for rescheduling the meeting should the student have a conflict with the scheduled time. The letter will include a statement indicating that if the student fails to appear for the meeting, that student waives the student's right to this administrative hearing process and a decision regarding responsibility and sanction will be assessed based on the available evidence. This judicial charge notice must be received by the student at least 72 hoursbefore an administrative hearing is convened to consider the matter.
4.	Students who fail to appear at the appointed time or fail to reschedule prior to the time of the original appointment waive their right to a hearing and may be assessed an appropriate sanction by the judicial hearing officer if responsibility is determined based on the evidence available.
5.	The administrative hearing is a one on one meeting between the student and the judicial hearing officer. The presence of an attorney and/or written materials submitted by an attorney in representation of his/her student client is prohibited. In the administrative hearing with the judicial hearing officer, the administrative procedures and charges will be explained, documentation and evidence will be reviewed, and the student will be provided the opportunity to have all pertinent questions answered. At the hearing the student and the judicial hearing officer will discuss the relevant information from the incident as well as any other information that the student or the judicial hearing officer deems appropriate.
6.	This hearing will result in one of the following possible outcomes:
	The hearing officer may dismiss the charge(s). The student may accept responsibility for the violation or may be found responsible by the hearing officer based on a preponderance of the evidence. A sanction (see section 7.1.2.8) will be verbally indicated by the hearing officer within 24 hours of the hearing, with written notification to follow within ten (10) College business days. In the event that a judicial hearing officer determines that additional information or further investigation is required in order to reach a decision, the outcome of the hearing will be delayed pending this investigation. The judicial hearing officer will follow up with the student to arrange any additional needed meeting(s) and/or to apprise the student of the investigations in progress. The process will conclude with a final decision regarding the hearing.
7.	The student who has been charged under the student conduct code may at the conclusion of the administrative hearing process choose to accept the decision/sanction or choose to have the case heard before the conduct review board. (See section 7.1.2.5.) If a case involves a graduating senior, the decision of the judicial hearing officer is final unless the decision/sanction involves withholding of a transcript or diploma, suspension, or expulsion. A decision/sanction involving withholding of a transcript or diploma, suspension, or expulsion may be appealed to the vice president for student affairs and campus life or designee.
8.	In cases of Sexual Misconduct or Domestic Violence the following additional procedures will be incorporated in the administrative hearing process: a. The primary witness and accused student will have the right to select an adviser from a specially trained pool of students, faculty and staff trained in the areas of domestic violence and sexual misconduct. The special adviser will help guide the primary witness/accused student through the judicial process., b. The administrative hearing will be conducted by both a male and female hearing officer. c. The primary witness will be given the opportunity to meet with the hearing officers to provide information about the case prior to the hearing. If a primary witness elects NOT to attend this meeting, the alternative options are handwritten, audio taped, or video- taped statements submitted 24 hours in advance of the hearing.

The student may also choose to have a conduct review board hear the student's case if the student has been charged under the residential life rules and regulations and the hearing officer has imposed a sanction of residence hall reassignment, residence hall restriction, and/or termination of the student's housing contract. No other sanctions imposed by a hearing officer regarding the residential life rules and regulations carry with them the option of a conduct review board hearing.

A written request for a conduct review board hearing must be received by the director of judicial affairs within 72 hours of the written notification of the sanction(s) from the administrative hearing.

In the event that a student is eligible to have the student's case heard before a conduct review board and chooses to do so, the decision rendered in the administrative hearing becomes null and void, and the student continues without sanction until the conduct review board hearing process is completed.

Takeaway: So I think it best to talk to an attorney before your proceeding, to discuss the impact of the criminal proceeding, and how it's outcome may be followed by resolving academic issues later on. Sometimes it also helps to let the College know you are accepting responsibility for your conduct, and being proactive about getting help. These things can go a long way to assist your long term college goals.

New York DWI Hardship License Privileges

Mandatory Ignition Interlock Devices (IID) and NY DWI

Well Friday, December 18, 2009 was a historic day. It was the first day that the "new" New York DWI laws took effect. It was thirty days from Governor Paterson's signing, and Ithaca City Court Judge Kerrigan mandated the first case of the day, my DWI case, with a sentence of a conditional discharge (one year - no new trouble ie. crimes), and a Ignition Interlock Device to be imposed for six months. This of course was in addition to the fines, NYS surcharge, mandated DDP (drinking driver program), and a one time VIP (Victim Impact Panel) for March 31, 2010.

All DWI convictions, whether for VTL DWI "per se" with a BAC .08 or higher, 1192 (2), or

VTL Aggravated DWI with a BAC .18 or higher, 1192 (2) (a), or VTL DWI "common law" 1192 (3) with no BAC will now have the mandatory imposition of a six month IID on their vehicles.

The applicable section of the new act is below:

(ii) In addition to the imposition of any fine or period of imprisonment set forth in this paragraph, the court shall also sentence such person convicted of a violation of subdivision two, two-a or three of section eleven hundred ninety-two of this article to a period of probation or conditional discharge, as a condition of which it shall order such person to install and maintain, in accordance with the provisions of section eleven hundred ninety-eight of this article, an ignition interlock device in any motor vehicle owned or operated by such person during the term of such probation or conditional discharge imposed for such violation of section eleven hundred ninety-two of this article and in no event for less than six months. Provided, however, the court may not authorize the operation of a motor vehicle by any person whose license or privilege to operate a motor vehicle has been revoked pursuant to the provisions of this section.

Information on Ignition Interlock Devices and/or installation / service centers, contact:

Ron Bergstrom

Community Corrections Rep I

NYS DPCA

80 Wolf Road, Suite 501

Albany, NY 12205

518 485-9941 or: Ron.bergstrom@dpca.state.ny.us

Company Websites and more information:

INTERCEPTOR IGNITION INTERLOCK INC.

(www.interceptorusa.com)

SENS-O-LOCK DETERMINATOR

(www.sens-o-lock.com)

INTOXALOCK BY CST, Inc. (call 877 777-5020)

(www.intoxalock.com)

DRAEGER SAFETY, INC.

(www.draeger-breathalyzer.com)

NATIONAL INTERLOCK SERVICE

Telephone For All: 1 800 871-5462 or (www.nationalinterlock.com)

SMART START

(www.smartstartinc.com)

There are a lot of problems with these devices in general. I will compare and discuss the various devices in future blogs as to reliability and ease of use.

2012 Update to IID BASICS or the Most Common FAQs

1. Is an IID a Must or a Should have?

The IID is not discretionary for NYS DWIs, it is Mandatory since August, 2010.

The Judges and the District Attorneys have no leeway or power here, if is a DWI (VTL 1192 (2), VTL 1192 (3), or ADWI (VTL 1192 (a) (a) then a device MUST be installed within 10 days of sentencing.

Bottom Line: There is NO plea bargaining concerning IIDs.

2. What if I live in another state?

It does not matter if you live in NYS or someplace else, you will have to get it installed. So if you live in PA, TX, or CA expect to hunt down an IID provider location, and then they will report back to the county monitor in NYS every 30 days. many of these IID providers have National Support. If you plan on moving (relocating) then plan on continuing monitoring as well. As long as the County Monitor is kept informed and updated it should not be a problem. The device must be downloaded at a physical location every 30 days.

Download times run 5 to 15 minutes. Some places can come out to your car with a handheld downloader.

I have not had the issue with "Out of the Country" (Foreign) License Holders unless they desired NYS privileges. My Canadian Clients end up with far worse consequences from their own country.

3. Could you just say (tell the Court) that you don't have (own) a car?

You could but it is still on your NYS DMV record, a hold will be in place by the county monitor (will be seen in any other state). With this new thing called the internet, and a National Registry of licenses:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Driver_Register

When you apply for a license or renew an existing license then they will run your record. If it shows up with a serious driving offense, like a DWI or DUI then the system is alerted. Your license (or driving privilege) in NYS will remain revoked UNTIL it is lifted by the County IID Monitor. If you choose NOT to comply with the NYS Court Ordered IID then other states will not give you (or renew) driving privileges either.

All Motor Vehicle Associations must check you under Federal Law 23 CFR 1327.5(b)(1). 

http://ecfr.gpoaccess.gov/cgi/t/text/text-idx?c=ecfr&rgn=div8&view=text&node=23:1.0.3.17.2.0.1.5&idno=23

4. What if You really don't Own a car?

It still remains on your NYS record, and the National Database as a revoked privilege/license. I have had clients have to borrow or buy cars to fulfill the Court obligation. They had a rental car, and were merely visiting NYS when they received a DWI. A Court Order is a Mandatory Obligation. It cannot be argued that you are in an unreasonable situation. In fact, a North Carolina client had to figure a way to get their car to a state with IID providers because North Carolina has none.  When I spoke to NYS DMV they just shrugged it off, not a perfect law by any stretch of the imagination. It has a great many issues with practical application in a day and age where people frequently travel, relocate, and are city dwellers.

5. Can it be installed prior to the Court's sentencing?

You "may" be able to get it installed BUT most places (providers) will NOT install it without the Court documents/final Court Order.

6. Are there differences between the units (IIDs)?

For sentences of a CD (Conditional Discharge) which is lieu of Probation and/or Jail, the Tompkins County Monitor has only been requiring a Class I (lowest level device). This one is the least expensive, and has NO camera. Higher level and naturally more costly devices have cameras to take your picture when blowing.

In Tompkins County, Probation sentences require the Class 3 device (with Camera) for the three year probation term.

7. Where Can I get one (an IID) in Tompkins County?

 In Tompkins County we have three main providers:

1. Route 366 and Route 13 next to AAA Motor Club, Autowerks (carries Smartstart IID vendor)

2. Highway Hi Fi, on Route 13 across from Papa John's Pizza Plaza.

3. Hunt's Auto service, Intoxalock Vendor, a little across from Tompkins Trust off Route 13.

Smart start was offering a free install, as an incentive, But I prefer the Intoxalock to avoid problems with the device's operation.

8. How do I get One installed?

You just call and say you need an IID, they will schedule you. Bring the final Court Order. Takes about an hour or less to install. Camera IIDs take longer because of the camera placement.

9. What else Must I do when installing the IID?

You must contact the County Monitor within 3 days of sentencing. It may be a different person if you are on a term of Probation versus receiving a CD (Conditional Discharge). Generally the minimum term for the device is 6 months, but some Judges place it on for 12 months or longer, even for a CD. All misdemeanor Probation terms are for three years.

The contact name and number for the Tompkins county IID monitor:

Michelle Barber:             Phone: 607-274-5461

Fax:  607-274-5429

Email: mbarber@tompkins-co.org

10. What Should I be aware of when installing the IID?

My Warnings: 

                           1. If the car that is getting the install has issues (mechanical and/or electrical) with the following it "can" affect the function of the device:

low battery

alternator voltage

defective horn

untimed engine

frequent stalling

Check the car out throughly before it gets this device installed. People that do not (screen and fix) or place it upon a junker are not usually happy because the device will malfunction. This can then provide the monitor with false readings of intoxication.

                           2. Do not drink the night before you drive, or else the device may be triggered from alcohol still in your system (body). 

WARNING: A BAC of .05 is an automatic Serious Violation/Failure that will require a Court Appearance.

                           3. Do not use cologne, perfume, mouth wash, toothpaste, mints while in the car or with anything that could trigger the device

11. How is the device set up and used?

The unit is calibrated for up to .25 BAC before it triggers but that said I would not rely upon that as a number because your body naturally produces some alcohol.

-the unit will demand a start up test

-then an initial rolling test (within a random interval ranging from 5 - 15 minutes) 

-subsequent rolling tests, not to exceed 30 minutes

They will (the installer) give you more information, these are merely some highlights. 

12. What if I am in found in Violation?

A violation of a CD will result in your being re-sentenced by the Court. The matter can be re-opened, you can receive jail time, you can receive three years of probation, you can receive a longer term for the IID to be in place.

Law Offices of Lawrence Newman

Lawrence (Larry) Newman, D.C., Esq.

Doctor of Chiropractic

Attorney and Counselor at Law

504 North Aurora Street

Ithaca, NY 14850

607-229-5184

http://www.ithacadwi.com

Dividing and Conquering the DWI

I am a fan of military movies. When I was young I loved to watch John Wayne, Clint Eastwood, and Charles Bronson. They were in my mind men's men. They were walking, talking confident leaders. In my memory, forever type cast as strong, wise, and tough conquerers. They fought for justice, freedom, and the pursuit of happiness.

When I think of my own career arcs, I have always fought or placed myself up against the establishment. When I was a Chiropractor, it was giving my patients the choice of using holistic and natural treatments rather than blindly following one size fits all modern-scientific medical dogma. At other times it was arguing with an insurance company who refused to pay for a procedure or denied benefits. As a lawyer practicing civil law, it was fighting hospitals, medical doctors, and their insurance companies.

Today, practicing DWI defense law, it is the New York State government, law enforcement, and their lawyers (the prosecutors). I am the check to the system. Often I work to set an imbalance. In other words, to create a more level playing field.

One basic premise behind DWI defense is that a case can be won if it is carefully and completely broken down into little pieces. The military theory behind it is called, "Defeat in Detail." You can defeat an enemy more easily by dividing their forces. As Lincoln said, "United we stand, divided we fall." Sun Tzu, said in classic military text, The Art of War, "Fracture the whole."

Any case becomes a story. Every story has chapters. Each chapter has a goal and a purpose. The story is usually of a person at the center of a police investigation.

While they (the government lawyers) are focusing on patterns and signs that focus on drunkenness. I break down the story into the good driving, normal walking, normal talking, normal thinking, normal responding, normal answering, and normal behavior into little bites of tailored information. Each chapter of my story highlights function, and normality. My story focuses on the missing pieces. Their stories embody red, bloodshot, watery eyes, slurred speech, and the strong odor of alcohol. Painting a picture of the fall down drunk. I am looking for all the other reasons (the reasonable doubt) for those same observations.

What is observed are always surface signs. Eyes can look watery at 1:30AM for many reasons, none having to do with the consumption of alcohol. The majority of people are not at their best in the middle of night, and the early morning hours.

So many questions need to be asked. How long have they been studying? How many hours sleep have you had the night before? What is the state of their health? What effect do red and blue flashing lights play in your performance? Or a huge flashlight thrust in your face? Were you nervous, upset, and scared? The term "performance anxiety" ring a bell. How well would anyone do at anything if they forced, under the gun so to speak to perform?

It's all how you look at it. It's the focus. It's the breakdown. It's the details. Make a list right now (while it is still fresh) of everything you did that was good, that was right, that was normal

on the night of your arrest. You will be surprised at how much of what you remember was normal.

What does Your DWI Lawyer Believe?

I have just turned the magic age of 48. Getting a bit more grey, having a few more excuse me "sirs" thrown my way pauses me to think, to reflect, and to question.

I feel extremely fortunate for my time here, my practice, and my opportunities. I have had 23 years of practicing both as a Chiropractic Physician, and as an Attorney at Law. Along the way I have had the pleasure and pain of helping thousands of people get through some of the worst times in their lives. I am at heart a caretaker. I am good at helping people heal. Whether with a word or a touch, it is my gift and ability.

I love to learn. What I have returned to again and again is that a person's beliefs will truly control and direct their destiny. At it's core, belief systems can be a series of convictions. Things that people are convinced about. They will fight to maintain them, and to honor their truth.

How many things do we believe in that are "true"? Only later to discover are false. They are propaganda, they are the ideas of others that we have bought into.

I caution those that pick counselors, choose leaders, and hire advisors to first find out what those people BELIEVE.

What does your doctor believe? Does he believe in the miracle of life and love? Does he believe that everything he was taught was fatal, actually is? Does he believe that the mind can affect the body? Does he believe that natural cures and remedies could work? Does he believe that everyone fits in the same box and should receive the same medicine? Does he buy into the value of rest, fresh air, and exercise? My father's doctors all smoked, and were overweight. They cautioned me about doing too much exercise. My father died of a third heart attack at the young age of 51. All his "trusted" doctors, his health advisors died early just like he did.

Now think about this for a moment, this is your doctor, and he is going to advise you, he is going to recommend treatment, he may even render a surgical opinion, how important is his belief system to the ultimate outcome of your care? It is everything! How he feels about drugs, food, surgery, and all else will color his advice to you.

Now take that understanding and perspective to the attorney that is going to represent you.

What does your DWI Defense attorney believe? Does he believe that the breath test is a very accurate, reliable, scientific, and valid measure of blood alcohol concentration? Does he believe that field sobriety tests are fair? Does he believe that the police officer's opinion, and his report are the truth?

I have met many attorneys whose belief systems are defeatist. They are sunk before they even begin. Where can you possibly go if you BUY into the prosecutor's machine result? What can you possibly argue with any heart or passion if you believe that your client is guilty as charged?

The reason why the best (I use that term with caution) DWI defense attorneys go to seminars (on the breath machines and field sobriety tests) is not only to gather knowledge BUT more importantly to topple belief systems. To challenge the reliability, accuracy, and validity of "objective" evidence. To change their minds about possible versus probable. To discover and uncover the natural and persistent doubt that goes with a great defense of the government's proof.

In my opinion the best DWI defense lawyers are SKEPTICS. They want to be shown, they are doubters, they are devil's advocates, they are in a word "difficult" and hard to convince.

What your lawyer and your doctor believe is very important to you and your future.

This is what I believe:

1. Machines are not perfect. They make mistakes. Even when they work perfectly they are subject to error. Often the people that use them use them incorrectly. Breath testing is convenient and cheap, it is not scientific, accurate, or reliable in it's current form.

2. All DWI cases must be looked at in detail, and the evidence must be gathered so that the situation can be looked at in the TOTALITY. How I feel about a case or advise a client will turn upon a full, fair, and realistic evaluation of everything.

3. Opinions are just that. A viewpoint, and a perspective, that have a bias, and that are highly subjective.

4. Lawyers need to understand what is important to their clients. My job is to guide, advise, and represent "their" interests being mindful of "their" values.

5. What people want, and what they can have may be world's apart. While lawyers can predict outcomes, we certainly cannot guarantee them. Many things are outside of our control. Judges, juries, and facts beyond change (accidents, prior convictions, chronologies, etc.) can impact final outcomes. When it comes to legal matters, You may want the cheerfulness of an optimist and hate the opinion of the pessimist, but what you really want is the advice of a realist.

Always ask your doctors, and your lawyers what they "believe" before you hire them to help you.

New York DWI Windows of Opportunity

Funny how the things you think about can relate to so many other things. This morning I remarked to my wife how the pear I was about to eat had such a brief period of perfect ripeness. No, I'm not high, but I do get these moments of insight. I have found that pears unlike apples are good, crisp, and delicious (not mealy) for only a few days. Cut them too soon and they are hard and bland. 

Then it hit me, DWI cases also have temporary windows of opportunity. The clock begins to run on every case when you are first arraigned with counsel. This is where you enter your plea of not guilty, and are formally told of the charges against you, by The People (of the State of New York).

Once you are arraigned your attorney must NOW make a demand for Discovery, and for a Bill of Particulars. This is the government's evidence against you (how they plan on proving their case). 

The District Attorney now has 15 days with which to comply with that demand. In addition, you have ONLY 45 days from this first date (the date of the initial appearance) to make, and to file any pre-trial motions. Motions to suppress evidence, Motions to suppress statements, Motions to Contest the use of the refusal against you, Motions to state that the stop and/or the arrest were unconstitutional.

Does your attorney serve the demand upon the District Attorney in Court (at the Initial Appearance)? 

Does your attorney wait? A few days? A few weeks? Does he send a letter? 

My philosophy is that:

1. The ADAs (Assistant District Attorneys) have a lot more cases (files) than I do. 

2. The government employees are typically overworked, and can not possibly know each and every file. 

3. I have more time to spend and think about fewer cases (because I take fewer cases).

4. I have more time to demand, gather, interpret, and study the evidence.

5. I have an advantage IF I use time as an opportunity.

6. There is now a greater likelihood that I will better understand the facts and the case.

7. The sooner I begin, the better my defense (s) to the evidence.

Attorneys are on strict timelines (deadlines). Meaning that if you DO NOT file motions in a timely manner you will lose your opportunity (your chance) to contest and argue them at pre-trial hearings. Too bad, so sad or if you snooze you lose. 

Pre-trial hearings (suppression hearings) are really where cases are truly won or lost. They are opportunities (G-d I love that word) where a lawyer can truly test his defense theories, size up the police officer, and create narrow and focused points of attack. 

So much like seizing that opportunity to eat a piece of fruit when it is perfectly ripe I believe it is vitally important to strike early, strike first, and strike hard with DWI cases. 

What happens at the NY DMV Drinking Driver Program and VIP Victim Impact Panels?

As a DWI defense lawyer I am often asked, "so what happens at the DDP (drinking driver program) and the VIPs (victim impact panel)?" If your scour the internet very little is divulged about either of these two programs. They do not admit attorneys because I have asked, and they do not even give out a curriculum. 

I am a curious person. I have a need to know about things. I am forever inquiring about How things work, and what procedures people follow. I admit I love to go on the internet and find stuff about stuff. Well all that I am about to reveal is after extensive surfing and research.

The completion of these programs is usually necessary to obtain a conditional driving license or privilege to drive in NYS, and to satisfy Conditions of the Court. The DDPs are ongoing programs but the VIPs are given at specific times and dates depending on the county you are in. Some Courts do not require out of state motorists to complete the VIP or the DDP but some require a like (similar) program's completion to satisfy a plea bargain.

Yates County, NY holds two VIPs per year whereas Tompkins County, NY has a VIP every three months. Some counties are just starting to form VIPs. 

How serious are the VIPs taken? Recently in Dryden, NY a person was sent to jail for a failure to attend the program on the specified date. Maybe it would have helped had he not stated in Court to the Judge that his reason for non-attendance was that he decided to go on vacation during the VIP date.

The DDP seeks to examine the arrest experience, evaluate the factors that led to the DWI arrest, and to help drivers make appropriate future driving decisions.

1. It is not merely a class but involves discussion among the participants about problems involving drug and alcohol abuse. Be prepared to interact, this is not a passive experience.

2. The program is seven (7) sessions in total. One (1) session per week. Each session lasts from two to three (2 to 3) hours. Total program time of sixteen (16) hours.

3. The first session discuss the reasons for the program (education and rehabilitation). 

NYS seeks to decrease the personal and property losses due to driving under the influence of drugs and/or alcohol.  The program's original intended goal was educational and not rehabilitative but that has changed over the last thirty years. I think because the political tenor of our country and Courts has shifted to adopt a AA position in regards to the treatment of alcohol and drug problems. The NYS DDP has been around for over 30 years in one form or another. 

4. As discussed before you will participate. You will fill out a drug/alcohol screening form (see the M.A.S.T.), usually the Michigan Alcohol Screening Test or like format. You will write about the night of your arrest, and the events proceeding it. The DDP wants you to look at your behavior, and what led you to this point in your life. This program is about self reflection.

5. There will be two instructors, one who is an alcoholism counselor, and one who is a highway safety expert. Session two will cover traffic safety and safe driving. There will be films to watch and discuss. The alcoholism counselor will decide whether further drug and alcohol evaluation is necessary for each of the participants.

6. Session three connects the use of drugs and/or alcohol with driving safety issues. Myths concerning drinking coffee or splashing cold water or listening to music to sober up are dispelled.

7. The fourth session deals with the physiologic effects of alcohol on the body, and it's various systems. What happens at various blood alcohol levels. How function and behavior are dramatically affected. How alcohol affects the central nervous system See the utube videos by Father Martin a proponent of AA.

http://www.youtube.com/user/fatherjoemartin

His videos have been used at the DDP. His views and emphasis are on the disease concept of addiction.

8. Session five and six deals with alcoholism as a disease, and discusses alcohol abuse detection. AA (alcoholics anonymous) is discussed and recommended by the DDP. 

9. Session nine is a summary of the course. The sessions as a whole were developed to instill healthy decision making, change the participants attitudes, and prevent future unsafe driving patterns.

The VIP (Victim Impact Panel)

It can run from one to three hours in length.

Some of the speakers will be professional counselors involved in rehabilitation.

Some of the speakers may be people affected directly by drunk driving.

There are usually people affiliated with AA (alcoholics anonymous) who present at the VIP.

You will be breath tested on arrival.

The doors will be locked so be prompt.

You will be observed so do not bring books, ipods, or any distractions or else you will be marked as absent.

Do not fall asleep or else you will be marked as absent.

Some of the ideas, history, and concepts presented in this blog were inspired and adapted from online articles, the book Drunk Driving "an American Dilemma" by James Jacobs, and assorted sources. It is presented merely as an education and information tool in response to many people who have asked me about what really goes on behind closed doors. 

Better Questions Yield Better Answers

What never ceases to amaze me in the game of life is the power of questions. The right question at the right place and right time can bring your thoughts into alignment and ultimately yield incredible answers.

This same thinking permeates the game of DWI defense.

So, What is the "evidence" of intoxication?

Yes, cases need to be proven, and they need to proven by the use of evidence. Each case has a set of facts but moreso we have a perspective of a witness or witnesses who will testify. They will not be testifying to mere facts. They will be giving their opinion about those facts by coloring them. What do I mean by coloring? Saying that you smell alcohol, and saying that you smell a strong odor of alcohol coming from the face or facial region are two different things. Yes, Virginia adjectives color. Saying someone was all over the road is different then saying they moved in and out of lane on two occasions within a 2 mile stretch of highway. Pronouns can color as well. Calling someone a defendant or an accused is not like calling them by their first name. This dehumanization is deliberate.

Truth is often a perspective. It is a biased opinion with or without color. My job as a professional problem solver is to seek out the best perspectives for my client. All facts have viewpoints.

A fact: a person has glassy, bloodshot, and watery eyes on the night or morning of their arrest.

WHY?

Was it because they were intoxicated or are there other reasons? Other Reasons or Causes yield doubt. Reasonable doubt is common sense doubt or common sense reasons other than they were drunk.

Were they tired? Were they sleepy? Were they sick? Were they suffering from a cold? Do they have allergies? Were their contacts in for too many hours? Were they exposed to smoke? Are their eyes normally like that? Was it because it was 3:00AM? Was it because they were crying? Was it because they just got slapped in the face? Was it because the weather outside was 10 degrees? Was it because their car air-conditioner dries their eyes?

Human beings come in all different shapes and sizes. We are not all the same. In fact, on any given day or time we may react differently to the exact same irritant. Why is this? Because we are dynamic, our bodies are constantly in flux, and our physiologies are continually adapting to a changing environment. Many of the indicators (signs) of intoxication match very closely with those of us who are sleep deprived, over worked, and just plain tired.

If I came to your house and woke you up at 3:00am, how well would you perform on balance-coordination exercises? How well would your brain be functioning? Would you understand my questions? Is it because you are intoxicated or disoriented or tired or confused or scared or nervous? Now imagine you are driving home, it was a nice dinner or party, it is late, you are ready for bed, all of a sudden... blue and red lights, your heart is racing, your throat is in your chest, you are perspiring heavily, we know where this is going... Your best defense is in asking the right questions.

Summer is Officially Here! The BWI (Boating While Intoxicated)

Practicing DWI defense in the Fingerlakes region of New York State, and living in Ithaca allows me the privilege of experiencing some amazing lake views. I love to witness Lake Cayuga go through the glory of all four seasons. Everytime I get in my car to appear in another town court in one of the many counties that surround the lakes I am taken back by the the incredible beauty of this area of the country. But of course, that is why I live and practice here, not by chance but by choice.

Summer does have it's drawbacks for me, there will be humid days and nights, lost tourists driving the wrong way down one of our many downtown one way streets, and the pain of yet again changing all the car tires from snows back to all seasons.

I kinda mark the beginning of "my" summer not with the end of school for my kids but by my first BWI phone call. To those not familiar, B.W.I. stands for, Boating While Intoxicated. It is a real criminal charge, and has alot of similarities to it's close cousin the NY DWI. NY BWIs fall under Navigation Law section 49-a. If you want a sleep aid, forget Ambien, go read through section 49-a.

My surfing has led me to conclude that there is little information about NY BWI on the web. There is also some confusing, and wrong information on the internet concerning New York BWI. I am planning on writing a more in depth article about it in the near future. In the meantime I wanted to hit the highlights:

1. Similar to DWI and DWAI there are a BWI (misdemeanor) and a BWAI (violation).
2. The legal standard (definition) for BWI (intoxication) and BWAI (impairment) for water operation of a craft are comprable to operation of a car or motorcycle on land.
3. You are only in danger of losing (suspension) your license to operate a boat not your car. The suspensions are 6 months and up for the BWAI, and a year for the BWI.
4. There are specific boating safety classes required with both BWAI and BWI.
5. The classes have to be either state sanctioned, US Coast Guard, or US Power Squadron safety classes.
6. There is a "contribution" (around $200) to the "I Love New York" Safe Boating Fund.
7. The fines range from $350- $500 for a BWAI, and $500- $1,000 for a BWI.
8. The BWI and BWAI will be reported on your New York DMV driving abstract, so your auto rates will eventually be affected by your boating charges. If you are from out of state it is likely that this will also go on your state's DMV record because NY has an interstate compact with many adjoining states.
9. The BWI is a criminal charge and will affect your entry into Canada in the future.
10.The BWAI violation is also going to affect your ability to enter Cananda because it is an alcohol related offense.
11. If you refuse the Breath Test back at the station (not to be confused with the preliminary breath test on the roadside) you will face many of the same consequences, ie. increased boating license loss, additional fines, as a DWI test refusal.
12. The BWI has a .08 BAC or >(breath alcohol concentration) standard, same as a DWI.
13. There will be additional NY state surcharges of around $240 for a BWAI, and $400 for a BWI.
14. There are two types of BWI, a BWI "per se" offense based only upon your BAC (.08 or >) and a BWI "common law" based upon the officer's observations, field sobriety testing, and other evidence of intoxication.
15. Since NY state has no expungement statute a BWI (misdemeanor) will remain on your permanent criminal record forever.
16. BWIs are defended much the same way as DWIs. The state (the prosecutor) still has the burden of proving you were intoxicated at the time of operation. The breath machine can be challenged for accuracy, validity, and reliability. The officer's tests can be shown to be administered improperly or scored with bias.

So my thoughts for today, let some else drive your boat, a designated "captain" so to speak. Enjoy the beauty of the lakes as a "passenger" if you want a few cold beers on a hot sunny day.